2010 Buffalo PizzaBash Results
Overall Winner (most votes for multiple items)- Just Pizza |
Best Crowd Favorite (Most votes in one category)- La Nova |
Best North Towns- Mister Pizza |
Best South Towns- Eatza My Pizza |
Best "Kept Secret" Pizzeria- Giangel's Cafe |
Best Pepperoni- Eatza My Pizza |
Best Cheese- La Nova |
Most Unique- Paddy's Pizza (Sheppard's Pie) |
Best Buffalo Style- Papa Leo's (Chicken Wing Pizza) |
Best Steak- Papa Leo's |
Best Chicken- D'Agostino's (Nicky D's Chicken Mediterranean) |
Best Veggie- Giangel's Cafe (Stuffed Hot Pepper) |
Best House- John's Pizza & Subs (Big Mack Pizza) |
Best Gourmet- Gianni Mazia's (Belly Dancer) |
Best Breakfast Pizza- Paddy's Pizza |
Best BBQ Pizza- Sugo Pizzeria (The Cowboy) |
Best Meat Lover- John & Mary's (The Man Pie-Chicken, Steak, Bacon, and Cheeseburger) |
Best Sauce- D'Agostino's |
Best White Pizza- La Costa Verde |
Best Loaded- Johnny LaBella's |
Best Thin Crust- Sal's Pizzeria |
Best Crust- Chick-N-Pizza Works |
Best "Grass" (Spinach Pizza)- La Costa Verde |
Best Specialty Pizza- Russell's Gourmet Pizza's (Turkey Gobbler- Turkey |
Sausage, Peach, and Goat Cheese, with balsamic drizzle) |
Best Parm Pizza- Sal's Pizzeria (Lasagna pizza) |
Pizza Bash Committee Award- Eatza My Pizza |
We had a special contest called the David vs. Goliath competition, which was La Nova vs. Giangel's Cafe. This was a contest created because the two pizzerias had come up with the same "Unique Creation". They both had made the Pot Roast Pizza, so we did a little celebrity taste challenge. Howard Simon and Jeremy White from WGR 550, and Joe from Celebrate Buffalo, did a blind taste test. They all chose #1 which was La Nova's based on the better pot roast pizza...but they all agreed on Giangel's for taste. Both were absolutely delicious!!!
Chick-N-Pizza Works had the crowd buzzing with a Perogie Pizza and Beef on Weck Pizza. These pizza's will be available at his stores, and believe me they were amazing! Another Note that has to be talked about is the amazing creations from Gr8 Pizza (Formally Bella Roma, on Delaware). He made a Braciole Pizza and Cannoli pizza. They couldn't participate on the first day, so votes were lower, but made a HUGE impact on Sunday!
Everyone left happy and that was for sure! The kids had a blast with Cookie Monster, Dora, and Optimus Prime. Plus they bounced and played up in the Pizza Play Zone, sponsored by Kidzplay. The adults enjoyed the music, Terry Buchwald, and got to watch all the tournament action in the Intertech Digital "Man Cave" area. The bellies were full and the smiles were ear to ear, and everyone can't wait until next year's Buffalo Pizza Bash.
Official Beverages of The Buffalo PizzaBash
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |










